|
Post by Charmed_boy on Dec 21, 2005 16:01:57 GMT -5
This forum is my latest forum and it is dedicated to all the other forums I made. It is mainly a forum to play thread games, the thing I like most to do in forums. You may also get Skins and Graphics. And there is also a small section to talk about Charmed www.CharmedSkins.co.nr
|
|
|
Post by stinky666 on Jan 4, 2006 21:27:22 GMT -5
The feedback/criticism i give, isnt meant to be taken harshly, it is just my opinions. Take my advice and comments as a good thing I concentrate on rating the following things: - Banner
- Menu Buttons
- Background
- Grads
- Color Scheme
(But i will comment on other things aswell ) For each section i rate, i give a rate out of 20, this then means i add the following together, which would then mean i get to a rate out of 100... Banner: The stocks on the banner are nicely blended, and the color is a simple grey scale color,but matches great with your whole color scheme. All of the font on the banner matches very well.. The effects on the banner are very plain and simple, this is what really lets the banner down. Maybe adding more effects of some kind, will improve it. Banner Rate: 17/20 Menu Buttons: The menu buttons are very nice, simpl, but nice. They really do match the forum very well. The size of them is also great, they are just the right size. Menu Button Rate: 19/20 Background: The background is very nice, also very simple and quite plain. But the thing with backgrounds, is people think they need to be fully of stock images or whatever. But with a background that has lots of effects or whatever on, makes the forum look really squished. Yours however looks and matches the forum perfectly. The colros of it also match perfectly. Background Rate: 19/20 Gradients: Your gradients, again, are very basic and plain, but for gradients you dont need to have too many effects on them. Yours match very well with the whole theme going on. The colors of them also match well with the whole forum. Gradients Rate: 17/20 Color Scheme: The whoel color scheme is absolutely great. I dont think ive seen a grey forum that looks superb. Everything seems to match with the whoel color scheme, even the link color. Color Scheme Rate: 20/20 Overall Rate: 92/100 = 9.2/10 Additional Comments: The on/off icons seem to match very well also. The table at the top of the forum though i think is slightly too big. Try removing some of those mini banners from it and putting them in with the bottom affiliates. The border around the forum compliments the forum very well..
|
|